9.2 Exceptional
New York, United States

Hotel Scherman

★★★★ — New York, United States
9.2 Exceptional
Overview

Hotel Scherman

First Impressions Hell's Kitchen has this energy that hits you the moment you step off the subway, and Hotel Scherman fits right into it — unpretentious, sharp, and genuinely welcoming.

First Impressions

Hell’s Kitchen has this energy that hits you the moment you step off the subway, and Hotel Scherman fits right into it — unpretentious, sharp, and genuinely welcoming. Walking in, you get the sense that this place knows exactly what it is: a well-run, four-star hotel that doesn’t need to shout about itself. The staff have that New York efficiency without the coldness, which honestly isn’t always easy to find in this city.

Location & Neighborhood

West 46th Street puts you in one of the most interesting pockets of Manhattan. You’re a short walk from Times Square, but far enough that you’re not drowning in tourist chaos every time you step outside. The neighborhood is packed with some of the best pre-theater restaurants in the city — think proper Italian spots and old-school diners that locals actually eat at. Couples especially seem to fall for this location, and it’s easy to see why: it’s walkable, lively without being overwhelming, and you’re never more than a few blocks from something worth doing.

The Room

Here’s the thing about Hotel Scherman — the beds are genuinely excellent. I mean, you hear that a lot, but guests consistently rave about the sleep quality here, and after a full day of walking Manhattan, that matters more than almost anything else. The rooms themselves are well thought out, with enough space to actually feel comfortable rather than just functional. It’s the kind of place where you come back after a long day and actually look forward to the room, which isn’t something you can say about every New York hotel at this price point.

Breakfast

Breakfast is a continental buffet setup, and it does the job well. You’ve got enough variety to fuel a proper sightseeing day without feeling like you’re just grabbing a sad pastry on the way out. It’s a relaxed way to start the morning — grab a coffee, sort out your plans for the day, and head out without having to hunt for a café first. Nothing overly complicated, but solid and satisfying, which is really all you need before hitting the streets of New York.

Why Guests Love It

The rating here sits at a 9.2, and honestly, that tracks. What Hotel Scherman gets right is the balance — great location, genuinely comfortable rooms, and a staff that seems to actually care about your stay. It’s not trying to be flashy, and that’s sort of the point. For couples especially, this place has a real appeal: you’re close to Broadway, close to great food, and you’ll sleep well after a full evening out. If you’re looking for a reliable, well-located base in Midtown Manhattan that delivers on the basics and then some, this is a very easy recommendation to make.

Guest Voices

Guest Reviews

9.2
Exceptional Based on 10 reviews
Staff
9.7
Comfort
9.5
Location
9.7
Free Wifi
9.4
Facilities
9.1
Cleanliness
9.5
Value for money
8.8
Filter:
R
Robert United States September 11, 2025
10

Perfect location in Hells Kitchen

Location location location

What could be improved: Everything was great. Staff, breakfast, comfortableness of bed all great

D
Dostalek United States September 10, 2025
10

The property was amazing. The staff was very welcoming and friendly

We love the location and the decor. The staff was amazing. We were treated to a complimentary upgrade. It was spectacular.

What could be improved: Not a thing. Love it

K
Katherine United Kingdom September 10, 2025
10

excellent location friendly staff great breakfast lovely room

The stay was lovely in general, like the roof top terrace for sitting out and soaking up the atmosphere we has an early trip to washington arranged and staff very kindly sorted take away breakfasts for us to take...

What could be improved: tiny small moan the air conditioning fans are located outside our room, were a tiny bit noisy

N
Neil United Kingdom September 9, 2025
10

Absolutely perfect

I loved that it was small and the bedrooms were big and airy The little balcony was great The breakfast was in a beautiful room The roof top terrace was a fabulous addition It was near to lots of fabulous restaurants and close to the shows and attractions The staff were fabulous and accomodating.They are happy for you to leave luggage on arrival before room is ready and as you are waiting for flights Was a great experience Thank you

C
Claudia United States September 9, 2025
10

Great choice if you want an excellent location and don’t like big chain hotels

The room was fantastic. The bathroom, the small living room (I was upgraded,without requesting, to a junior suite, yay!!!). The staff was really nice and welcoming too.

What could be improved: The kitchenette furniture do need a little TLC. They look a bit run down. The bathroom, although perfectly clean and nice needs some grout attention b ‘cause some parts of it look moldy…

R
Rossen Bulgaria September 7, 2025
8

Charming traditional and cosy hotel.

Location, spacious room, charming vintage style, comfy beds and pillows, rooftop terrace

What could be improved: Room view, room lighting, A/C right above the bed, narrow hallways, very basic breakfast.

S
Shelly United States September 7, 2025
10

Would definitely recommend this quaint hotel.

Very cute boutique hotel. Small but beautiful. Perfect location for the cruise terminal. Love the rooftop terrace. The shower was huge! Lots of restaurants within walking distance.

What could be improved: The one and only elevator was a little scary. Every time we got on it would drop an inch or two.

M
Marie Ireland September 7, 2025
10

Made our short stay in NYC

Beautiful spacious room with a lovely street view. Extremely comfortable bed. Friendly and helpful staff. Great location.

What could be improved: Breakfast was only OK, but this was not an issue for us as we are not big breakfast people. Plenty of nice coffee shops very close by.

S
Simon United Kingdom September 6, 2025
10

Highly recommended hotel with great staff

Beautiful little hotel in Restaurant Row about a three min walk from Times Square

What could be improved: The shower in our room wasn’t very good

J
Joseph United States September 5, 2025
10

Overall we enjoyed being close to the action but far away enough to not be hampered by all the Times Square noise.

Great location and the suit was a solid size.

What could be improved: Although breakfast was included, I anticipated a few more things would be available; however, with so many choices around the hotel it wasn’t a huge issue or deterrent.

Find Us

Location

346 West 46th Street, Hell's Kitchen, New York, NY 10036, United States

Surroundings

What's nearby:

  • Grace Plaza900 m
  • Balsley Park900 m
  • Central Park850 m
  • Verizon Plaza950 m
  • Liberty Theater700 m
  • Ramon Aponte Park250 m
  • Rainbow Playground200 m
  • 246 W 38th St Tenants900 m
  • Madame Tussauds New York600 m
  • Matthews - Palmer Playground250 m

Restaurants & cafes:

  • Restaurant Chai150 m
  • Restaurant Swing 46150 m
  • Restaurant Sushi of Gari 461 m

Top attractions:

  • Bryant Park1.2 km
  • Top of the Rock1.1 km
  • Chrysler Building1.8 km
  • Flatiron Building2.5 km
  • Strawberry Fields2.3 km
  • The Highline Park2.3 km
  • Rockefeller Center1.2 km
  • Museum of Modern Art1.5 km
  • Empire State Building1.7 km
  • Metropolitan Museum of Art3.7 km

Natural Beauty:

  • Lake The Lake2.5 km
  • Peak Kings Bluff (31m)4.5 km

Public transit:

  • Train Penn Station1.3 km
  • Subway50 Th Street Station450 m
  • Train New York Penn Station1.6 km
  • Subway42nd Street – Port Authority Bus Terminal450 m

Closest Airports:

  • La Guardia Airport12 km
  • Teterboro Airport15 km
  • New York Skyports Seaplane Base3.8 km
Reserve Your Stay

Hotel Scherman

New York, United States

Get in Touch

Send Us a Message

Fill out the form below, and one of our concierge specialists will get back to you promptly.





    Looking for the perfect place to stay?
    I'll help you find the best stay in New York!