9.1 Exceptional
New York, United States

Broadway Plaza Hotel

★★★★ — New York, United States
9.1 Exceptional
Overview

Broadway Plaza Hotel

First Impressions Walking into the Broadway Plaza Hotel, you immediately get that classic New York vibe without the stuffiness that some four-star places can have.

First Impressions

Walking into the Broadway Plaza Hotel, you immediately get that classic New York vibe without the stuffiness that some four-star places can have. The lobby’s got this welcoming energy — not too flashy, but definitely polished enough that you feel like you’ve made a good choice. What struck me right away was how the staff actually seemed to know what they were doing, which honestly isn’t always a given in Manhattan hotels. The whole place has this comfortable sophistication that works whether you’re here for business or just exploring the city.

Location & Neighborhood

You know what’s brilliant about this spot? You’re right in NoMad, which means you get the best of both worlds — close enough to Midtown’s action but far enough away that you’re not drowning in Times Square chaos. I mean, you can walk to the Empire State Building in about ten minutes, and Madison Square Garden is practically next door. The subway connections here are fantastic too — you’ve got multiple lines within a few blocks, so getting anywhere in the city is actually pretty painless. Plus, there are some genuinely good restaurants in the immediate area that aren’t just tourist traps.

The Room Experience

The rooms at Broadway Plaza Hotel are where this place really shines, and I get why couples rate the location so highly — there’s something about the setup that just works for a romantic getaway. The beds are legitimately comfortable (not just hotel marketing speak), and I actually slept better than I expected to in the middle of Manhattan. The rooms aren’t huge — this is New York, after all — but they’re smartly designed so you don’t feel cramped. The bathrooms are clean and modern, and you get decent water pressure, which can be hit or miss in older NYC buildings.

Practical Perks

What I appreciated most were the little things that make a difference when you’re actually staying somewhere. The WiFi works properly throughout the building, the elevators don’t take forever, and there’s usually someone at the front desk who can give you real recommendations rather than just handing you a tourist brochure. The hotel sits in what’s genuinely one of the best-rated areas in the city, and you can feel it — there’s this energy where you’re connected to everything without being overwhelmed by it. The neighborhood feels safe walking around at night, which matters when you want to grab dinner or just explore.

Why Guests Love It

Honestly, this hotel gets the balance right in a way that’s harder to find than you’d think. It’s polished enough that you feel good about staying here, but not so formal that you can’t relax after a long day of sightseeing. The location score speaks for itself — when couples are rating it nearly perfect for romantic trips, that tells you something about both the hotel and the neighborhood. You’re paying for a solid four-star experience in one of the city’s most desirable areas, and you actually get what you pay for, which in New York hospitality is honestly refreshing.

Guest Voices

Guest Reviews

9.1
Exceptional Based on 10 reviews
Staff
9.6
Comfort
9.5
Location
9.7
Free Wifi
9.2
Facilities
9.0
Cleanliness
9.4
Value for money
8.8
Filter:
R
Rorgatt Canada September 10, 2025
8

Very Good

The hotel was very welcoming and the staff helpful. Anthony was great. Check-in was fast and efficient. Rooms were updated, comfortable and spacious. Loved the decor.

What could be improved: When I booked it, I did not realize how far a walk it was from the theatre district. The doors are very heavy and tend to slam shut. The rooms need a little bit more soundproofing as the person in the next room loved to sing at 5:00 am and was quite loud but eventually settled down.

L
Liam United Kingdom September 3, 2025
10

A great base for a couples trip to NYC!

The hotel is beautiful and excellently located! Rooms are spacious, well decorated and clean! The staff are incredibly helpful and warm and can't help you enough if you need something! I booked a terrace room for my girlfriend and I to meet up with my family for my sister's 21st birthday. Our room was great and the view from our terrace, wow!! The Empire State in all its glory!! I would definitely recommend it and I will definitely stay again when returning to NYC!

What could be improved: N/A

L
Liam United Kingdom September 3, 2025
10

The hotel is beautiful and excellently located! Rooms are spacious, well decorated and clean!

The hotel is beautiful and excellently located! Rooms are spacious, well decorated and clean! The staff are incredibly helpful and warm and can't help you enough if you need something! I booked these two rooms for my family for my sister's 21st birthday and the staff were incredibly kind and welcoming to my family who checked in before me as I was arriving on a separate internal flight! I can't thank the hotel and staff enough for providing a great base for my sister to enjoy her birthday weekend in The Big Apple!

What could be improved: N/A

S
Sarah United Kingdom September 3, 2025
10

Exceptional

Staff were superb. Very welcoming and attentive.
Cleaning staff very thorough with their cleaning regime.

What could be improved: Two chairs in the room would have been better.
Perhaps windows could be triple glazed to keep out noise from Broadway

D
David Australia August 30, 2025
9

Broadway Plaza - great location, great service, comfy rooms

Great location, comfortable room, nice staff

What could be improved: Nothing in view of the good pricing

A
Aya Israel August 30, 2025
10

Perfect stay

Amazing view, spacious and clean room. The location can’t be better

M
Marla United States August 27, 2025
9

Wonderful

It was a great place. We were up on the higher floor so it was quiet and the view was perfect!

M
Maristela Brazil August 26, 2025
8

Very Good

Spacious bedroom and great location
The bellmen were very efficient and polite, unfortunately I didn’t get their names to mention

What could be improved: Windows are poorly soundproofed, I could hear the street noise at night

C
Cristiano United States August 25, 2025
9

Great Stay

Location is great! staff was amazing and room were clean and comfortable. The parking discount is also great!!!

J
Jacinth United States August 10, 2025
10

Comfortable landing spot

The water was replaced everyday, the housekeeping staff did a great job, the front office staff were always pleasant & welcoming. Very comfortable room after a day of exploring.

What could be improved: I can't think of anything I didn't like

Find Us

Location

1155 Broadway, NoMad, New York, NY 10001, United States

Surroundings

What's nearby:

  • Herald Square650 m
  • Museum At Fit500 m
  • Jemmys Dog Run400 m
  • Flatiron Building400 m
  • Madison Square Park300 m
  • Empire State Building650 m
  • Morgan Library & Museum1.1 km
  • Center For Jewish History1 km
  • Yeshiva University Museum950 m
  • Marcus Garvey Memorial Park500 m

Restaurants & cafes:

  • Restaurant Il Fiorista100 m
  • Restaurant Cha Cha Matcha50 m
  • Restaurant Oakberry Acai Bowls40 m

Top attractions:

  • Bryant Park1.3 km
  • Brooklyn Bridge5 km
  • Top of the Rock2 km
  • Chrysler Building1.8 km
  • Strawberry Fields3.9 km
  • The Highline Park1.7 km
  • Rockefeller Center2 km
  • Museum of Modern Art2.3 km
  • One World Trade Center4.4 km
  • National September 11 Memorial & Museum4.3 km

Natural Beauty:

  • Lake The Lake4.1 km
  • Peak Kings Bluff (31m)5 km

Public transit:

  • Train Penn Station1.1 km
  • Train New York Penn Station850 m
  • Subway23 Rd Street Bmt Broadway Line350 m
  • Subway28 Th Street Bmt Broadway Line100 m

Closest Airports:

  • La Guardia Airport13 km
  • Teterboro Airport16 km
  • New York Skyports Seaplane Base1.8 km
Reserve Your Stay

Broadway Plaza Hotel

New York, United States

Get in Touch

Send Us a Message

Fill out the form below, and one of our concierge specialists will get back to you promptly.





    Looking for the perfect place to stay?
    I'll help you find the best stay in New York!