8.4 Excellent
New York, United States

The Marlton Hotel

★★★★ — New York, United States
8.4 Excellent
Overview

The Marlton Hotel

First Impressions Walking up to The Marlton Hotel on West 8th Street, you'd almost miss it if you weren't looking — and that's exactly the point.

First Impressions

Walking up to The Marlton Hotel on West 8th Street, you’d almost miss it if you weren’t looking — and that’s exactly the point. This four-star boutique property sits quietly among the brownstones and cafes of Greenwich Village, with just a subtle sign marking what’s actually one of Manhattan’s most charming small hotels. The lobby feels more like stepping into a well-appointed friend’s apartment than a typical hotel, with dark wood paneling and vintage touches that somehow manage to feel both historic and completely current.

Location & Neighborhood

Honestly, you can’t do much better than this spot in the Village. I mean, you’re literally surrounded by some of the city’s best coffee shops, bookstores, and restaurants — the kind of places locals actually go to, not just tourist traps. Washington Square Park is a two-minute walk, which means you get that quintessential New York experience without the Midtown chaos. The couples who stay here clearly get it (they rate the location 9.7), and I can see why — there’s something romantic about wandering these tree-lined streets that you just don’t find in other parts of Manhattan.

The Rooms

The rooms at The Marlton Hotel are compact but thoughtfully designed, which is exactly what you want in the Village. What really stands out are the beds — seriously comfortable, and apparently other guests agree because the hotel consistently gets praised for them. The design leans into that literary, old-New York vibe with rich fabrics and carefully chosen antiques, though everything feels fresh rather than dusty. You know what I appreciate? The attention to details like proper lighting for reading and enough outlets for your devices, which shows they actually think about how people use hotel rooms.

The Experience

There’s something special about the service here that keeps people coming back — and I mean literally, because this place has more repeat guests than most hotels in the city. The staff seems to genuinely know the neighborhood and can point you toward that perfect little wine bar or the bakery that opens early for proper croissants. It’s not stuffy or overly formal, just genuinely helpful in that way that makes you feel like you’ve discovered something rather than just booked a room.

Why Guests Love It

The Marlton Hotel works because it captures what people actually want from a Village stay — authenticity without sacrificing comfort. You’re not paying for a massive lobby or a rooftop pool you’ll never use; instead, you’re getting a prime location, a really good night’s sleep, and that feeling of being a temporary local rather than just another tourist. The fact that so many people return says everything you need to know about whether this place delivers on its promise of being your home base for exploring one of New York’s most beloved neighborhoods.

Accommodations

Our Rooms

Double Room

Max. people: 2
1 full bed
From $561 / night
Select Room →

Queen Room

Max. people: 2
1 queen bed
From $591 / night
Select Room →

Deluxe Queen Room

Max. people: 2
1 queen bed
From $669 / night
Select Room →
Guest Voices

Guest Reviews

8.4
Excellent Based on 10 reviews
Staff
8.9
Comfort
8.8
Location
9.5
Free Wifi
8.8
Facilities
8.3
Cleanliness
8.6
Value for money
7.6
Filter:
G
Gillian United States September 9, 2025
8

Classy NYC hotel with beautiful rooms and a lovely breakfast setting.

Classy style, has charm, loved the breakfast and the staff were great. Location was also great for my needs. The room amenities, such as the robe, slippers, and toiletries were a nice added touch.

What could be improved: I really wish they had a door person--there are stairs to enter the lobby and there is no one to even open the door for you, let alone help you up the stairs with the heavy door and your bags.

S
Susan United States August 25, 2025
9

just lovely. felt like i was in london.

everything

What could be improved: the proximity of the hall door to the staircase. a little tricky opening the door with luggage etc. My friends independently mentioned the same thing. the stairs should be carpeted for safety

C
Cassidy United Kingdom August 15, 2025
9

Excellent location and lovely staff would recommend!

The staff were extremely friendly. The front desk staff in particular.

What could be improved: The complimentary breakfast felt a little lazy. Not much choice.

D
David United States August 2, 2025
9

Great atmosphere in Greenwitch Village. Nice parlor, library area to have wine, coffee

Nice boutique hotel and great staff!

What could be improved: Smaller rooms

M
Mia United States August 2, 2025
9

I had a wonderful time. Will stay here again!

Comfortable, clean, stylish, great location, really good restaurant!

What could be improved: Always too cold in the lobby and restaurant even on hot days. Terrible pillows, I mean terrible! Other guests smoking.

A
Aidan Ireland July 29, 2025
7

Enjoyable stay in a great location!

Great location, the style of the hotel, multiple and fast lifts (as can be an issue in NY), clean, bed was comfortable, majority of employees were very helpful and friendly.

What could be improved: No water refill facility in the hotel other than asking the bar. Very small room (but I acknowledge this is pretty standard for NY, and fine for one night stay), we encountered one very rude employee when picking up our room key the evening we checked in, but other than him, everyone else was extremely welcoming and helpful.

S
Sarah Belgium July 25, 2025
9

Beautiful room and neighborhood

We loved everything about the room and the location.

What could be improved: The included breakfast is okay, but isn't free since you're still expected to tip (that's obviously okay, but us europeans tend to forget this). However, the prices displayed for the breakfast you get are way too much for what you get. To be honest the whole breakfast situation was a bit confusing.

K
Karen United States July 4, 2025
8

Like traveling to Paris!

Location and ambiance. Feels like you’re staying on the left bank in Paris! Fabulous lounge and restaurant.

What could be improved: Elevator - needs refurbishment. Bedroom exceptionally small.

A
Aktürk Germany June 15, 2025
7

Comfortable, Historical, Rude Staff

The bed was so comfortable. I had everything in the room that I needed. (water, snacks, slipers, iron)

I like the neighborhood and the breakfast in the hotel and the design of the hotel.

What could be improved: The room was so small there was no space to sit just bed for sleeping. So I wanted to sit in the lobby where there are nice coaches. But everytime the staff interrupted me and asked me if I am from hotel. It felt so disturbing. And one time a staff (knows that I am from hotel) asked me to move to a different chair because she wanted a different group to sit there and the area was empty.
Nice ambience but comparing to what I had and the money I paid, it is a bit overprised.

B
Bruce Australia June 7, 2025
9

The short stay at the Marlton was a positive experience; the room and amenities, location and service were all appreciat

The property retains a lot of its original features which is interesting. The room was clean and the bed was comfortable. The location is also very convenient.

Find Us

Location

5 West 8th Street, Greenwich Village, New York, NY 10011, United States

Surroundings

What's nearby:

  • Georges Dog Run350 m
  • Mc Carthy Square600 m
  • Christopher Park500 m
  • Golden Swan Garden450 m
  • Minetta Playground500 m
  • West 4th Street Courts550 m
  • Sheridan Square Viewing Garden600 m
  • Washington Square Park-East Ent350 m
  • Washington Square Park-West Ent250 m
  • Washington Square Park-South Ent300 m

Restaurants & cafes:

  • Restaurant La Panineria20 m
  • Restaurant Eva's Supplements30 m
  • Restaurant South of the Clouds150 m

Top attractions:

  • Bryant Park2.9 km
  • Brooklyn Bridge3.8 km
  • Top of the Rock3.5 km
  • Chrysler Building3.2 km
  • Flatiron Building1.2 km
  • The Highline Park2.2 km
  • Rockefeller Center3.5 km
  • Empire State Building2.1 km
  • One World Trade Center2.9 km
  • National September 11 Memorial & Museum2.8 km

Natural Beauty:

  • Lake Reservoir No 36 km
  • Peak Kings Bluff (31m)6 km

Public transit:

  • Subway9th Street300 m
  • Train Penn Station South2.1 km
  • Train Astor Place Subway Station550 m
  • Subway West 4th Street-Washington Square550 m

Closest Airports:

  • La Guardia Airport16 km
  • Teterboro Airport18 km
  • New York Skyports Seaplane Base2.6 km
Reserve Your Stay

The Marlton Hotel

New York, United States

Get in Touch

Send Us a Message

Fill out the form below, and one of our concierge specialists will get back to you promptly.





    Looking for the perfect place to stay?
    I'll help you find the best stay in New York!