8.3 Excellent
New York, United States

The Manhattan Club

★★★★ — New York, United States
8.3 Excellent
Overview

The Manhattan Club

First Impressions Walking into The Manhattan Club, you immediately get that classic New York hotel vibe — polished but not stuffy, busy but organized.

First Impressions

Walking into The Manhattan Club, you immediately get that classic New York hotel vibe — polished but not stuffy, busy but organized. The lobby has this timeless elegance that feels authentically Manhattan without trying too hard. What struck me right away was how the staff seemed to genuinely know what they were doing, which honestly isn’t always a given in this city. You can tell this four-star property has been around long enough to figure out the details that matter.

Prime Midtown Location

The location on West 56th Street is honestly pretty perfect if you want to be in the thick of things. You’re literally a few blocks from Central Park, Times Square is walkable (though you might not always want to walk there), and Carnegie Hall is practically next door. I mean, couples rate the location 9.5 out of 10, and I get why — you can stroll to Lincoln Center for a show, grab dinner in Hell’s Kitchen, or just people-watch your way through some of the best blocks in Manhattan. The subway access is solid too, which matters when your feet inevitably give out from all that city exploring.

The Rooms

Here’s what I really appreciated about staying at The Manhattan Club — the beds are actually as comfortable as they claim. You know how hotels always promise great sleep but then you’re lying there at 2 AM listening to sirens and feeling every spring? Not here. The rooms have this cozy, residential feel that’s refreshing after dealing with the chaos outside. They’re not huge (this is Manhattan, after all), but they’re thoughtfully laid out with enough space to spread out your stuff without feeling cramped.

Morning Routine

The breakfast situation works well for different travel styles — they do continental breakfast if you want to sit and ease into your day, but they also have grab-and-go options for when you’re rushing off to catch a Broadway matinee or meet friends in Brooklyn. I actually used both during my stay, depending on what the day looked like. The coffee is decent, and honestly, having any breakfast included in Midtown is a win since everything around here will cost you at least $15 for a bagel and coffee.

Why Guests Love It

What makes The Manhattan Club work is that it strikes this nice balance between being genuinely comfortable and being right where you want to be in the city. You’re not paying for unnecessary bells and whistles, but you’re also not sacrificing quality or location. The staff knows the neighborhood well enough to point you toward the good stuff, and the whole place has this lived-in feeling that makes it easy to come back to after long days of museum-hopping or shopping. Plus, when couples consistently rate the location that highly, you know you’re in a spot that’s actually enjoyable to explore together rather than just convenient on paper.

New York’s apartments offer urban accommodations with skyline views, perfect for families wanting to experience daily life in this culturally rich American metropolis.

Accommodations

Our Rooms

Executive Junior Suite

Max. people: 2
1 sofa bed, 1 queen bed
From $377 / night
Select Room →

City Lights Suite

Max. people: 2
1 sofa bed, 1 queen bed
From $403 / night
Select Room →

One-Bedroom Suite

Max. people: 2
1 king bed, 1 sofa bed
From $466 / night
Select Room →

Deluxe King Suite

Max. people: 2
1 king bed, 1 sofa bed
From $594 / night
Select Room →

Junior Suite with Balcony

Max. people: 3
1 full bed, 1 sofa bed
From $551 / night
Select Room →

King Suite with Balcony

Max. people: 3
1 queen bed, 1 sofa bed
From $679 / night
Select Room →

Superior King Suite

Max. people: 3
1 queen bed, 1 sofa bed
From $1,222 / night
Select Room →
Guest Voices

Guest Reviews

8.3
Excellent Based on 10 reviews
Staff
8.9
Comfort
8.6
Location
9.6
Free Wifi
8.2
Facilities
8.1
Cleanliness
8.6
Value for money
7.9
Filter:
J
Jan Czech Republic August 28, 2025
9

Excelent location and very close to Central Park and Times square

Location and the room 2219, very nice view.

D
Davide United States August 27, 2025
7

Good

Room, location and service/staff was all great.

What could be improved: Hotel feels small and tight, but it's quite normal for Manhattan. Room was actually bigger than expected, great.

T
Titilope United Kingdom August 24, 2025
8

Very Good

Location was excellent.

F
Faisal United Kingdom August 23, 2025
9

A phenomenal New York stay – the best I’ve ever had in the city, with outstanding staff and a truly grand feel!

Everything about this stay was phenomenal. The location was absolutely perfect – and I’ve been to New York about 10 times, this was hands down the best experience, second to none. The hotel had a lovely, grand feel and the staff were so friendly and helpful throughout. Even when I accidentally left something in the room after checking out, they made sure it was returned to me straight away. The whole place felt superb – from the atmosphere to the service, it was brilliant all around.

What could be improved: The TVs were very outdated with no smart features, which made them basically unusable. Even the channels were limited and confusing, so I couldn’t really unwind with TV in the evenings. That’s the only thing I’d say needs improvement. Made for boring nights in the room.

S
Scott United States August 22, 2025
7

Not the Ritz, but nice for a night in the City.

Nice location and wonderful staff

What could be improved: Junior suite with terrace pictures in Booking.com were not representative of the dark reality. The “terrace was just a narrow balcony. Our bedroom had no windows and was dark. The elevator situation was poor (Not enough capacity). The cabinets in the room were flimsy and misaligned. It just was not “luxury”. It was adequate at best.

E
Evelyn United States August 14, 2025
7

Good property but some staff shouldn’t be there.

Great location surrounded by restaurants, souvenir stores, shops.

What could be improved: The description shows great views of the city but in our visit they gave us the room with the worst view. It was completely obstructed and in the 2nd floor. Not to mention that the bellboy at our arrived was so mean and disrespectful. He took my bags and yelled at me when tried to take the elevator with my husband and 2 kids, to give me a note that I didnt even know what was it for, after half an hour of being waiting for my luggage I realized he put my bags in their luggage storage instead of taking them to my room. Totally lost of what he was supposed to do. I even had to go to the lobby again and look for my own bags in their storage as they couldn’t find them themselves.

L
Livy United States August 14, 2025
7

Convenient, comfortable and clean stay!

The bed was comfortable, the bathrooms were decently lit and sized, and there were a couple of full sized mirrors which is an added bonus!

What could be improved: The elevators were so slow and my friends and I had to end up walking down 23 flights of stairs on check out day because everyone was checking out at the same time and the elevators were slow nd kept being full.

J
Jeannine United States August 10, 2025
9

Overall experience was great! Would absolutely recommend staying here!

Staff, location

What could be improved: Sofa bed was uncomfortable

K
Khadija United States August 6, 2025
8

We had a great experience. The hotel is very clean and close to subway station.

Close to everything.

M
Maysam Sweden August 6, 2025
9

Wonderful

We stayed at this hotel as a family of four, and the room size was perfect for us. Having a counter with a sink, a dishwasher, and cabinets stocked with dishes was very convenient and added a nice touch of comfort and luxury. The furniture and curtains had a charming antique New York style, which gave the room a unique character. The location was also excellent, just a short walk from Times Square.

What could be improved: The downside, however, was the cleanliness. The sofas had some visible dirt. Also, although we were four guests, the sofa bed was not set up when we checked in. We ended up setting it up ourselves and had to call the staff to bring us sheets and pillows.

Find Us

Location

200 West 56th Street, New York, NY 10019, United States

Surroundings

What's nearby:

  • Cop Cot450 m
  • Balsley Park500 m
  • Central Park0 m
  • Fermi Playground450 m
  • Columbus Monument350 m
  • Museum of Modern Art700 m
  • 120 Central Park South450 m
  • The Paley Center For Media750 m
  • Central Park-South Entrance550 m
  • Central Park Rock at 7th Avenue Playground100 m

Restaurants & cafes:

  • Cafe/Bar Starbucks20 m
  • Restaurant Redeye Grill50 m
  • Cafe/Bar Epicerie Boulud150 m

Top attractions:

  • Bryant Park1.6 km
  • Top of the Rock950 m
  • Chrysler Building2.2 km
  • Flatiron Building2.9 km
  • Strawberry Fields1.4 km
  • The Highline Park3.5 km
  • Rockefeller Center1 km
  • Empire State Building2.2 km
  • One World Trade Center7 km
  • Metropolitan Museum of Art2.6 km

Natural Beauty:

  • Lake The Lake1.7 km
  • Peak Kings Bluff (31m)5 km

Public transit:

  • Train Cruise Line Terminal1.5 km
  • Train Grand Central Station2 km
  • Subway57th Street - Midtown350 m
  • Subway57th Street-7th Avenue150 m

Closest Airports:

  • La Guardia Airport11 km
  • Teterboro Airport16 km
  • New York Skyports Seaplane Base4.2 km
Reserve Your Stay

The Manhattan Club

New York, United States

Get in Touch

Send Us a Message

Fill out the form below, and one of our concierge specialists will get back to you promptly.





    Looking for the perfect place to stay?
    I'll help you find the best stay in New York!