The Historic Blue Moon Hotel – NYC
First Impressions Walking up to The Historic Blue Moon Hotel – NYC, you get this immediate sense that the building has stories to tell.
First Impressions
Walking up to The Historic Blue Moon Hotel – NYC, you get this immediate sense that the building has stories to tell. It’s tucked into the Lower East Side, and honestly, that neighborhood alone sets the tone — gritty in the best way, layered with history, and nothing like the sanitized midtown hotel strips. The facade has that old New York character you don’t really find anymore, and stepping inside feels like a genuine discovery rather than just checking into another four-star property.
Location & Neighborhood
The Lower East Side is one of those areas that rewards curious travelers. You’re surrounded by some of the city’s best delis, vintage shops, and late-night spots — places that actual New Yorkers go to, not just tourists. The hotel scores a 9.0 for location, and I’d say that’s well earned. Couples especially seem to click with this neighborhood — there’s something about its mix of old-school charm and buzzy energy that makes it feel romantic without being cheesy. You’re also close enough to SoHo, Chinatown, and the East Village that getting around feels effortless.
The Rooms
The rooms here lean into the building’s history rather than trying to cover it up, which I appreciate. You’ll notice thoughtful details — exposed brick, period touches — that give each space a personality of its own. It’s a four-star hotel, so don’t expect anything over-the-top, but the comfort level is solid and the atmosphere more than compensates. I mean, staying somewhere with actual character beats a generic chain room any day of the week.
Breakfast
Breakfast is genuinely one of the stronger points here, and it’s worth factoring into your stay. The spread covers a lot of ground — Italian options, vegetarian dishes, halal and kosher choices, all laid out buffet-style. That kind of range is honestly rare, and it means pretty much everyone at the table is going to find something they’re happy with. It’s the sort of breakfast that sets you up properly before a full day of walking the city, which in New York, you absolutely will be doing.
Why Guests Love It
The hotel sits at a 7.7 overall rating, and when you break that down, the location score of 9.0 is doing a lot of the heavy lifting — in the best possible way. Couples in particular rate it a 9.2 for a two-person trip, and honestly, you can see why. There’s something about the combination of a historically rich building, a neighborhood full of personality, and a breakfast that actually caters to different needs that makes the whole experience feel considered rather than cookie-cutter. If you want a New York stay that feels rooted in the real city rather than a polished version of it, The Historic Blue Moon Hotel – NYC is worth a serious look.
New York hotels provide guests with comfortable accommodations in this never-sleeping city, known for its Broadway shows, world-class museums, and legendary shopping districts.
Our Rooms
Luxury Junior Suite with Balcony
Max. people: 3Quintessential King with Balcony
Max. people: 4Guest Reviews
Comfortable and spacious room in an excellent location for exploring the city. However, would not stay there again given
Great location, very nice room. Comfortable, clean, and spacious.
What could be improved: The hotel is right above a loud night club which makes it difficult to sleep. Also they required us to pay $30 to check in early even though the room was available and clean. Further, they has no secure place to store luggage after we checked out. They store their luggage in a staircase of the hotel that the front desk is not watching.
fun, eccentric hotel in great area
They allowed us to keep our bags in the lobby outside of our stay, the room was a great size and the bed was huge and extremely comfortable. Great value for money and lots of great cafes/restaurants and shops right outside the hotel
Excellent value for money in a retro hotel.
Good size room with personal digital access code. Very comfortable bed and bathroom was clean and bright. Staff are very helpful and courteous. Hotel is in a good location only a 5 min walk to the nearest subway and a choice of bars and cafes all within the local area.
What could be improved: No safe in room they are located in the basement area and housekeeping has to be requested if you require a daily clean.
No place like it.
This place is a vibe. There is nothing like it. The people who run it are characters. The food is amazing. Super confortable rooms and bigger than you would expect. I was surprised to find this place. This will be my go to in NYC now.
We will be back!
The staff is amazing--friendly, helpful, and responsive. We felt as if we were guests in their home.
Great location, great boutique hotel, lovely history and detail.
Small boutique hotel, great detail, comfortable room.
What could be improved: Didn’t understand the stove in the middle of my room. No vent, small sink, no real kitchen wares so why?
We loved our stay, it was a charming hotel with a kind staff.
Very nice boutique hotel. The owner showed us his personal art on the walls and was very friendly. The young man at the front desk was super helpful and friendly as well. A train station is a couple blocks away. Plenty of great restaurants around.
What could be improved: The shower pressure was a little low but did the job, I understand it’s an old building.
Beautiful hotel, great location, would come back!
The Historic Blue Moon hotel is a beautiful building! We so appreciate the preservation and the little details that went into the space. Staff was kind and there is always someone at the front desk. Location was prime and we never fell short of finding things to do. Additionally, we were surprised at how quiet it was at night despite it being a busy street.
What could be improved: The doors do slam quite loudly so we often heard our neighbors or the housekeeping folks who went in and out. Also, not a big deal but wanting to note there is no microwave in the rooms or ice.
Beautifully restored hotel, but had negative interactions with Staff.
The hotel is decorated nicely, theme of the rooms are cute.
What could be improved: The staff made an error during check-in and assigned us to the wrong room. There were no problems until our last night when we discovered staff had entered our room without our knowledge or permission to, “check if someone who shouldn’t be there is staying there.” Our contact information was on file at the front desk, and instead of waiting for us to return to rectify the issue, staff entered our room and looked around while our belongings were not put away because we had our “Do Not Disturb” sign posted and assumed that would be honored. When we returned, they incessantly implied that we asked for/switched to a different room upon check-in. Then staff came up to our room again, asking if we had been in the room our whole stay or had just switched rooms. My husband went downstairs to investigate the issue further to which they asked again if we switched rooms - which was when we found out they went into our room while we were gone, leading us to believe they were never going to inform us of this fact. What was once a lovely trip is now soured by this invasion of privacy, something I believe is valuable to the establishment as well as the staff’s inability to accept THEY had made the mistake. Furthermore upon checkout, our car did not have space on the street to load our belongings so we asked for display signs to be moved to the sidewalk to utilize the Hotel’s “Loading/Unloading Zone” where our vehicle was approached multiple times by the Owner and Staff to say I couldn’t park there to which I repeated multiple times that I was not parking and in fact, loading luggage in the designated zone. Staff continued to rush my husband and I out of their hotel despite the fact that my husband has a visible, physical disability that requires walking assistance with a cane. It’s a shame to have missed a private tour with the Owner of the establishment but we will not be returning. Thank you.
Very Good
Funky and cool
What could be improved: The DL has loud dance music on the east side of the building till 4am on weekends
Location
Surroundings
What's nearby:
- First Park600 m
- New Museum650 m
- Nike Field600 m
- ABC Playground550 m
- Strauss Square400 m
- Katzs Delicatessen500 m
- Essex Crossing Park400 m
- Hua Mei Bird Garden350 m
- Washington Square Park600 m
- First Street Green Art Park700 m
Restaurants & cafes:
- Cafe/Bar The Casino50 m
- Restaurant Adventure Cafe30 m
- Restaurant Excuse My French10 m
Top attractions:
- Bryant Park4.6 km
- Brooklyn Bridge2.5 km
- Top of the Rock5 km
- Chrysler Building4.4 km
- Flatiron Building2.9 km
- The Highline Park4.2 km
- Rockefeller Center5 km
- Empire State Building3.8 km
- One World Trade Center2.6 km
- National September 11 Memorial & Museum2.5 km
Natural Beauty:
- Lake Reservoir No 36 km
- Peak Laurel Hill (26m)7 km
Public transit:
- Subway Grand Street450 m
- Train Astor Place Subway Station1.5 km
- Subway Delancey Street-Essex Street150 m
- Train Brooklyn Bridge – City Hall1.8 km
Closest Airports:
- La Guardia Airport15 km
- New York Skyports Seaplane Base2.6 km
- John F. Kennedy International Airport16 km
The Historic Blue Moon Hotel – NYC
New York, United States
Send Us a Message
Fill out the form below, and one of our concierge specialists will get back to you promptly.


