San Carlos Hotel New York
First Impressions Walking into the San Carlos Hotel New York feels like stepping into a piece of Manhattan history that's been carefully polished for modern travelers.
First Impressions
Walking into the San Carlos Hotel New York feels like stepping into a piece of Manhattan history that’s been carefully polished for modern travelers. The lobby has this intimate, boutique feel that’s honestly refreshing after dealing with some of the massive, impersonal hotels you’ll find elsewhere in the city. It’s not trying too hard to impress — just solid, classic New York hospitality with enough character to make you feel like you’ve discovered something special rather than just booked another room.
Prime Midtown Location
You know what really struck me about this four-star hotel? The location is absolutely perfect for couples — and I can see why they consistently rate it so highly. You’re right on East 50th Street in Midtown East, which means you can walk to Rockefeller Center in about five minutes, and Times Square is just a pleasant stroll away. But here’s the thing — you’re tucked away enough that you’re not dealing with the complete chaos of the tourist epicenter. The neighborhood has this nice mix of business energy during the day and that classic New York evening vibe, plus you’ve got excellent subway access at 51st Street.
The Rooms
I have to say, the beds at San Carlos Hotel New York really live up to their reputation. After walking around Manhattan all day, sinking into one of these beds actually feels like a small miracle — they’ve clearly invested in quality mattresses and bedding. The rooms themselves have a comfortable, understated elegance that works well for the space. They’re not huge (this is Manhattan, after all), but they’re thoughtfully designed so you don’t feel cramped, and the windows let in good natural light during the day.
Neighborhood Perks
What I really appreciate about staying here is how easy it makes exploring the city. You’re within walking distance of some fantastic restaurants — I mean, you’ve got everything from casual delis to upscale dining within a few blocks. The area around East 50th has this great mix of locals and visitors, so you get authentic New York energy without feeling like you’re stuck in a tourist bubble. Plus, if you need to grab anything, there are plenty of shops and services right in the neighborhood, which honestly makes a difference when you’re staying several days.
Why Guests Love It
The San Carlos Hotel New York hits that sweet spot where you get genuine New York character without sacrificing comfort or convenience. It’s the kind of place where couples particularly seem to thrive — probably because the location gives you easy access to romantic dinner spots and cultural attractions, while the hotel itself provides a cozy retreat from the city’s intensity. The staff clearly knows the neighborhood well and can point you toward hidden gems, and that high location rating isn’t just numbers — it’s the real experience of being perfectly positioned to enjoy everything Manhattan has to offer while having a peaceful place to return to each night.
Travelers should reserve a hotel in New York at least three months ahead for major events like marathons and holiday celebrations, ensuring the best rates and prime locations near popular Manhattan attractions.
Our Rooms
Premier Suite with Queen Bed with 1 ½ bath
Max. people: 2Guest Reviews
Exceptional
The location couldn't be better- close to the main attractions. Professional staff. Cleanliness above avarage. Spacoius room and bathroom. Absolutely 10.
What could be improved: -
Perfect hotel in a great location
Great hotel, very quiet for NYC. Rooms were large with a little kitchenette which was perfect for breakfast and making tea and coffee.
Would definitely recommend!
What could be improved: Nothing it was great
It was a pleasant stay.
It was in a good location
Would recommend and would stay here again.
Friendly & helpful staff. Great location. Big rooms with good facilities.
What could be improved: Nothing
Wonderful
Great location, lovely staff
We enjoyed our stay and would return to San Carlos when in NYC again!
No breakfast!
We like the hotel,staff,services,location but the rooms are looking somewhat dated!
Good, functional hotel, especially nice if you want an extra bathroom.
We appreciated how close to the main museums and the park the hotel was. Our premier suite was spacious with an extra 1/2 bath, a keurig, fridge and microwave. We stayed a week and the keurig was refilled daily. There was also a set of glass dishware that we used almost every day and it was replaced, clean each day. Our daughter stayed on the pull out couch and said it was comfortable. There are two separate air conditioners which made it easy to adjust temps in the bedroom and the living room.
What could be improved: The room is tired, but functional. Everything works but the carpet is worn and coming up in places, paint is scraping off, etc. It's an older place. But the main issues we had were the noise, the lack of ability to clean dishes and the curtains did not make the room fully dark--the windows do not shut out noise and the air condition turning on and off all night is also very noisy. There is no dish soap or anything to clean with. We would have appreciated being able to use the dishes more. There are curtains but they are more fancy then functional so they don't fully cover the windows which meant the room had more light than we like. There are no working USB plugs or upgraded plugs for electronics. The alarm clock had and old docking station but that wasn't very useful.
Great Hotel in NYC - Midtown East
We stayed in the junior suite and it was the perfect size for relaxing after a long day of site-seeing.
The room was clean and the staff was friendly, accommodating, and helpful. We especially appreciated the efficient daily cleaning staff.
The location was also good, walkable and close to public transportation. While close to many attractions, the hotel is quiet, tucked away from excessive street noise.
What could be improved: The decor was slightly dated (nothing significant) but the price was adjusted accordingly.
Very easy to get to plenty of attractions and a safe pleasant neighbourhood.
The staff were very welcoming and friendly and happy to do anything to make our stay go well.
What could be improved: Bathroom getting a bit dated.
Exceptional
Perfect location, close to most museums, size of the room, kitchenette, and cleanliness.
Staff were able to accommodate all our requests
What could be improved: Nothing
Location
Surroundings
What's nearby:
- Cohen Park700 m
- Paley Park700 m
- Radio Park650 m
- Central Park550 m
- Mac Arthur Park650 m
- Channel Gardens650 m
- Top of the Rock800 m
- Chrysler Building650 m
- Park Avenue Plaza450 m
- Rockefeller Center700 m
Restaurants & cafes:
- Restaurant Bistango3 m
- Restaurant Empire Steak House10 m
- Restaurant New York Luncheonette30 m
Top attractions:
- Bryant Park1.5 km
- Brooklyn Bridge6 km
- Flatiron Building2.7 km
- Strawberry Fields2.8 km
- The Highline Park4.2 km
- Museum of Modern Art850 m
- Empire State Building2 km
- One World Trade Center8 km
- Metropolitan Museum of Art3.4 km
- The Paley Center For Media850 m
Natural Beauty:
- Peak Kings Bluff (31m)6 km
- Lake Conservatory Water2.4 km
Public transit:
- Train Grand Central Station900 m
- Train New York Penn Station2.8 km
- Subway Fifth Avenue/53Rd Street300 m
- Subway51 St Street Lexington Avenue Line150 m
Closest Airports:
- La Guardia Airport8 km
- Teterboro Airport17 km
- New York Skyports Seaplane Base2.9 km
San Carlos Hotel New York
New York, United States
Send Us a Message
Fill out the form below, and one of our concierge specialists will get back to you promptly.


