8.7 Excellent
New York, United States

Carnegie Hotel

★★★★ — New York, United States
8.7 Excellent
Overview

Carnegie Hotel

First Impressions Walking into the Carnegie Hotel, you immediately get that classic New York boutique vibe — it's intimate without feeling cramped, elegant without being stuffy.

First Impressions

Walking into the Carnegie Hotel, you immediately get that classic New York boutique vibe — it’s intimate without feeling cramped, elegant without being stuffy. The lobby has this warm, welcoming energy that honestly surprised me given how many Midtown hotels can feel a bit corporate. You know what struck me most? The staff actually seemed to recognize returning guests, which is pretty rare for a four-star property in this part of the city.

Prime Midtown Location

The location on West 56th Street is absolutely stellar — I mean, couples rate it 9.7 out of 10, and after staying here, I totally get why. You’re literally steps from Carnegie Hall (hence the name), and Central Park is just a quick two-block walk north. What I love about this spot is that you’re close enough to Times Square to catch a show, but far enough away to actually get some sleep. The subway access is fantastic too — the N, Q, R, and W trains at 57th Street are right there, plus you’ve got the F train at 57th and 6th.

The Rooms

Here’s where Carnegie Hotel really shines — the beds are genuinely exceptional. I’m usually pretty skeptical when hotels boast about their bedding, but honestly, I slept better here than I have at some five-star places. The rooms themselves are classic New York style, which means they’re not huge, but they’re smartly designed with good storage and surprisingly quiet considering you’re in the heart of Midtown. The bathrooms are well-appointed, and I appreciated the thoughtful touches like the quality toiletries and the fact that the shower actually has decent water pressure.

Breakfast Experience

The breakfast setup offers both continental and buffet options, which gives you some flexibility depending on whether you’re rushing off to meetings or taking a leisurely morning. The continental spread is solid — fresh pastries, good coffee, and the usual suspects you’d expect. If you go for the buffet, there’s enough variety to keep you satisfied, though don’t expect anything too elaborate. What I actually preferred was grabbing something quick from their continental selection and eating it while planning my day — the lobby area has some comfortable seating that works well for this.

Why Guests Love It

The Carnegie Hotel hits that sweet spot where location, comfort, and value intersect in a way that’s hard to find in Midtown Manhattan. You’re paying for a four-star experience and actually getting it, which isn’t always guaranteed in this neighborhood. The combination of those incredibly comfortable beds, the prime location that couples especially rave about, and the genuine hospitality makes it feel more personal than your typical Midtown business hotel. It’s the kind of place where you can walk to Lincoln Center for an evening performance, grab dinner in Hell’s Kitchen, and still feel like you’re staying somewhere with character rather than just another anonymous hotel room.

To book a hotel in New York during major events like Fashion Week, travelers need early planning as this vibrant city draws visitors eager to experience its dynamic energy and world-famous skyline.

Accommodations

Our Rooms

Superior King Room

Max. people: 2
1 king bed
From $391 / night
Select Room →

Double Room

Max. people: 2
1 full bed
From $439 / night
Select Room →
Guest Voices

Guest Reviews

8.7
Excellent Based on 10 reviews
Staff
9.4
Comfort
9.2
Location
9.6
Free Wifi
9.2
Facilities
8.6
Cleanliness
9.1
Value for money
8.2
Filter:
D
Deborah United States September 7, 2025
9

would def recommend…much more intimate than your average nyc hotel.

intimate and exceptionally clean hotel in a great location with a very welcoming staff. and no wait for the elevators , which is a pet peeve of mine.

What could be improved: the room had no view and was a bit small.

H
Hans Greece September 2, 2025
10

This is your next stay in New York

Perfect location, perfect staff. Very clean and comfortable rooms. Cleaning Service was amazing. Couldn't be better. Did I mention the location ? Outstanding !

What could be improved: Breakfast is nice but basic, if at all possible a slight enlargement of the breakfast area would make the experience even better.

K
Kim United States August 31, 2025
10

It was great and very comfortable!

Location, cleanliness, staff were so helpful and nice, free breakfast, wine and cheese every day at 5 pm, and felt safe.

What could be improved: Would have liked to make coffee in our room (have a coffee maker). Loud noises outside from construction and vehicles.

T
Tim United States August 30, 2025
10

Great hotel

Great location and nice modern room

B
Barbara Georgia August 23, 2025
9

Great experience! Will definitely stay again.

The staff were great! The breakfast options were perfect.

L
Leigh United States August 21, 2025
10

Could not have been better.

Everything was exceptional. Location, Luggage storage, staff, clean room, comfortable bed and pillows, great bathroom with excellent water pressure in the shower, snacks and coffee, wine and cheese happy hour … everything was just outstanding.

C
Carly United States August 18, 2025
9

Wonderful

The staff was truly amazing. From front desk to the service and conversation during the complimentary wine and cheese. The room was clean and the bathroom was particularly lovely with great products.

A
Aurora United States August 15, 2025
10

Exceptional

It was in a great location. Surrounded by many restaurants and souvenir shops. It was just two blocks from Central Park! Everything we wanted to see was within walking distance. The main woman at the reception desk was so great, also. Made us feel very welcome! I wish I could remember her name. She was awesome.

What could be improved: The hotel sent me a text stating I had been downgraded to a Queen Room due to HVAC issues. I was disappointed to have been given a smaller room when I paid for a King room. Upon check-in I was still under the impression I would be receiving a Queen Room but was happy it was a King once we entered the room.

D
David United States August 14, 2025
9

Not sure we could have picked a better hotel than the Carnegie!

Great mid-town location! Walking distance to the Park, Times. Sq, St Patrick's, Rock Center et al. (Patsy's was a block and a half away! Molto bene!) We were on the eighth floor directly across from Carnegie Hall - we were able to open a window slightly to capture some fresh air - some street noise with window open but total silence just by closing the window and turning on AC. Very comfortable bed and large walk- in shower. We were a little off-put at first by having no coffee machine in the room but it turned out to be totally unnecessary with the availability of 24/7 (free) beverages in lobby. I believe there's only 4 rooms to a floor (that I saw) so the elevator was just steps from the room. Took literally 5 minutes to go to the lobby and get multiple cups of coffee and place on a tray and return to the room. Hotel also offers breakfast in the morning and snacks with wine in the evening. When I was traveling for work - this hotel would have been very near the top of my list of great places to stay. Staff was very welcoming and helpful! Rating 9.9. Well done, Carnegie Hotel! (PS: also loved the lobby mural with past Carnegie Hall performers)

What could be improved: We didn't see a luggage rack in the closet (?) so we had to place our luggage bags on the floor- not a big deal- but it does take up some floor space in the room.

R
Rob United Kingdom August 13, 2025
10

Exceptional

Comfortable, clean, stylish.
Friendly, helpful staff.
Excellent location.
Plentiful breakfast.
Cheese & wine.

What could be improved: It was a bit crowded at breakfast, as the space is small.

Find Us

Location

160 West 56th Street, New York, NY 10019, United States

Surroundings

What's nearby:

  • Cop Cot500 m
  • Trump Tower550 m
  • Central Park0 m
  • Fermi Playground500 m
  • Columbus Monument450 m
  • Museum of Modern Art600 m
  • 120 Central Park South500 m
  • The Paley Center For Media650 m
  • Central Park-South Entrance500 m
  • Central Park Rock at 7th Avenue Playground100 m

Restaurants & cafes:

  • Cafe/Bar Ines Carnegie50 m
  • Restaurant Souvlaki GR10 m
  • Restaurant Redeye Grill50 m

Top attractions:

  • Bryant Park1.6 km
  • Top of the Rock850 m
  • Chrysler Building2.1 km
  • Flatiron Building2.8 km
  • Strawberry Fields1.5 km
  • The Highline Park3.6 km
  • Rockefeller Center900 m
  • Empire State Building2.1 km
  • One World Trade Center8 km
  • Metropolitan Museum of Art2.6 km

Natural Beauty:

  • Lake The Lake1.8 km
  • Peak Kings Bluff (31m)5 km

Public transit:

  • Train Cruise Line Terminal1.6 km
  • Train Grand Central Station1.9 km
  • Subway57th Street - Midtown250 m
  • Subway57th Street-7th Avenue100 m

Closest Airports:

  • La Guardia Airport11 km
  • Teterboro Airport17 km
  • New York Skyports Seaplane Base4.2 km
Reserve Your Stay

Carnegie Hotel

New York, United States

Get in Touch

Send Us a Message

Fill out the form below, and one of our concierge specialists will get back to you promptly.





    Looking for the perfect place to stay?
    I'll help you find the best stay in New York!