7.3 Very Good
New York, United States

City Club Hotel

★★★★ — New York, United States
7.3 Very Good
Overview

City Club Hotel

First Impressions Walking into City Club Hotel feels like stepping into one of those classic New York stories you hear about — you know, the kind where someone discovers a hidden gem right in the thick of everything.

First Impressions

Walking into City Club Hotel feels like stepping into one of those classic New York stories you hear about — you know, the kind where someone discovers a hidden gem right in the thick of everything. The lobby has this understated elegance that doesn’t try too hard, which I honestly appreciate after seeing so many hotels that go overboard with the marble and gold. It’s a four-star property that knows exactly what it is, and there’s something refreshing about that confidence.

Prime Midtown Location

Here’s what really gets me about this place — you’re literally at 55 West 44th Street, which means you’re basically in the center of the universe if you’re trying to do New York properly. Times Square is a quick walk, but you’re far enough away that you won’t hear the Elmo costumes arguing at 2 AM. Bryant Park is right there (perfect for morning coffee), and honestly, the subway access is incredible. I mean, couples rate the location 9.0 out of 10, and after spending time in the area, I totally get why. You can walk to most Broadway shows, hit up the best restaurants, and still feel like you’re staying somewhere with actual character.

The Rooms

The rooms at City Club Hotel have this classic New York vibe — not huge, but smartly designed in a way that actually works. You’ll find everything you need without feeling cramped, which is honestly a minor miracle in Midtown Manhattan. The windows give you real city views (not just brick walls), and the beds are genuinely comfortable after long days of walking around the city. What I really appreciated was how quiet it stays despite being in such a busy area — good soundproofing makes all the difference when you’re trying to sleep in the city that never does.

Breakfast and Dining

The continental breakfast situation is pretty solid — nothing fancy, but it gets the job done before you head out to explore. You’ve got your standard options, and the coffee is actually decent, which matters more than you might think when you’re gearing up for a full day in New York. What’s great is that if you want something more substantial, you’re surrounded by incredible breakfast spots within a few blocks. The hotel’s location means you’re never more than a minute from amazing bagels or that perfect New York deli experience.

Why Guests Love It

Look, City Club Hotel isn’t trying to be the flashiest place in town, and that’s exactly why it works so well. You get a genuinely comfortable stay in one of the best possible locations without paying those crazy upscale hotel prices. The staff knows the neighborhood inside and out, so they’ll point you toward the good stuff — like which subway entrance to use or where to grab late-night food that doesn’t suck. It’s the kind of place where you feel like you’re actually staying in New York, not just visiting it from some isolated hotel bubble.

Accommodations

Our Rooms

Queen Luxe Room

Max. people: 2
1 queen bed
From $419 / night
Select Room →

King Luxe Room

Max. people: 2
1 twin bed, 1 king bed
From $469 / night
Select Room →

Luxe 2 Double Beds Room

Max. people: 2
1 twin bed, 2 full beds
From $519 / night
Select Room →

Grand Duplex

Max. people: 2
1 king bed, 1 sofa bed
From $663 / night
Select Room →

Two Connecting Queen Rooms

Max. people: 2
2 sofa beds, 2 queen beds
From $1,105 / night
Select Room →
Guest Voices

Guest Reviews

7.3
Very Good Based on 10 reviews
Staff
8.1
Comfort
7.7
Location
9.1
Facilities
7.2
Cleanliness
7.6
Value for money
7.3
Filter:
S
Sandra United States September 5, 2025
8

I’d stay here again because it was clean and convenient and the price was right!

Staff, location and room
Was really nice and cold
And quiet!!!

What could be improved: Didn’t have a gathering space or lobby area. Also, breakfast should have a good protein like boiled eggs.lots of sweet cereals and breads!

S
Sandra United States September 1, 2025
8

Great location, clean and very very nice and accommodating staff!

They were very accommodating and let me check in early. I didn’t get the cream of the crop room but I figured that would be the case by checking in early. Very comfy room with a good a/c and a huge bathroom with a bidet! It was a perfect location from the park, Grand Central, 5th Ave, etc. A great coffee machine that made strong espresso.

What could be improved: The didn’t offer any protein at the breakfast…lots of carb options and fruit. Also, if you need a space to gather with friends, there is no lobby for this.

L
Lisa United Kingdom August 24, 2025
8

Amazing stay in this fab hotel

Great central location
Comfortable bed with fresh cotton sheets
Best shower ever, amazing flow and fluffy white towels.
Good choice for breakfast, good coffee
All staff were professional and welcoming- really contributed to a fantastic stay in New York

M
Michelle United States July 2, 2025
8

Very nice hotel and will visit again.

The location was great! Walking distance to Times Square and many other attractions. The staff very friendly and accommodating. Our room was clean spacious.

D
Daiva United States June 22, 2025
6

Pleasant

Location, room was clean

What could be improved: The staff not

S
Suzanne United Kingdom May 31, 2025
8

Great family room in a fabulous location

The hotel is in an excellent location. The room was perfect for 5 people, but it got very hot at night if you didn't have the air-conditioning on. We managed fine as we weren't in the room very much! Great selection at breakfast. A very laid back feel to the hotel which was great - thanks to all the staff.

What could be improved: It was a bit cold for the person sleeping in the single sofa bed, as it was right next to the air conditioning unit.

Lack of wardrobe space for a family of 5.

S
Sarah United States April 29, 2025
8

Perfect for a solo traveler who wants privacy and a location away from a busy street.,

It was quiet, clean, comfortable, in a good location, as well as being reasonably priced.

What could be improved: It was pretty shabby in the hallways and the elevator.

A
Alessia Switzerland April 28, 2025
8

we enjoyed very much our stay!

the location is perfect. the room was very clean an spacious.

What could be improved: there could be more variety for the breakfast selection. no view.

B
Bakiaj United States April 26, 2025
8

Staff is great

Location

What could be improved: U can barely see the hotel 🤔 needs a big sign upfront

S
Seiko United States April 19, 2025
8

Comfortable spacious hotel room.

The location location location.

What could be improved: Breakfast. The staff at the breakfast seemed very irritated. The complimentary breakfast is nice, but very basic.

Find Us

Location

55 West 44th Street, New York, NY 10036, United States

Surroundings

What's nearby:

  • Radio Park700 m
  • Bryant Park450 m
  • Grace Plaza150 m
  • Verizon Plaza250 m
  • Channel Gardens650 m
  • Liberty Theater750 m
  • Top of the Rock550 m
  • Chrysler Building800 m
  • Rockefeller Center650 m
  • Madame Tussauds New York650 m

Restaurants & cafes:

  • Restaurant D B Bistro0 m
  • Restaurant Proper Food100 m
  • Restaurant Lantern's Keep0 m

Top attractions:

  • Central Park3.6 km
  • Flatiron Building1.9 km
  • Strawberry Fields2.7 km
  • The Highline Park3 km
  • Museum of Modern Art900 m
  • Empire State Building1.2 km
  • One World Trade Center6 km
  • Metropolitan Museum of Art3.5 km
  • The Paley Center For Media850 m
  • National September 11 Memorial & Museum6 km

Natural Beauty:

  • Lake The Lake2.7 km
  • Peak Kings Bluff (31m)5 km

Public transit:

  • Train Grand Central Station650 m
  • Train New York Penn Station1.5 km
  • Subway Fifth Avenue €“ Bryant Park450 m
  • Subway42 Nd Street -€“ Bryant Park250 m

Closest Airports:

  • La Guardia Airport10 km
  • Teterboro Airport16 km
  • New York Skyports Seaplane Base3.2 km
Reserve Your Stay

City Club Hotel

New York, United States

Get in Touch

Send Us a Message

Fill out the form below, and one of our concierge specialists will get back to you promptly.





    Looking for the perfect place to stay?
    I'll help you find the best stay in New York!